An SEO Experiment

photo credit: Svadilfari
First of all, If you’ve been here before you might notice that I’ve changed WP themes. The reason is that my previous one quit working for no particular reason (hacked?) and because I’ve been too busy (or lazy) I just turned on the default WordPress theme for a couple of weeks until I got around to dealing with it. Sorry about that.
The SEO Experiment
I have a couple of SEO questions that so far I haven’t been able to get a satisfying answer to.
- For organic search rank (not type in traffic, or navigational searches that include the TLD) does a domain name which is an exact or near match for the query phrase rank higher – all other things being equal.
- If the answer to that is yes, and the exact match domain is 301ed to another domain does it pass that higher ranking?
Because of some work that I’ve been doing I think that the answer to both of these questions is yes. But, my evidence is anecdotal, and I know that I could be wrong. However if I’m right this could be a useful tool.
So, I’m going to do an experiment to attempt to answer these two questions. Here’s what I have in mind:
- Obtain several domain names (at least 3 but more would be better) that consist of more or less random combinations of letters. Ideally they would be of equal length, bought at the same time and perhaps alphabetically sequential. I have to control the cost of the experiment so ideally these would be nice cheap .info domain names.
- Also obtain two or more .com domains that are an exact match for a bogus key phrase(s). The main point of this is to target valuable long tail searches so these domains would need to reflect this goal, thus – abc-defg-hijk.com or abcdefghijk.com although the distribution of vowels and consonants should be at least word like. There should be 0 results for a Google search of the bogus key phrase “abc defg hijk”.
- Set up bare bones web sites for each domain on the same shared host. While not ideal for real SEO this should help to prevent hosting from being a factor in relative rank.
- The web pages should be very simple plain vanilla html with no style formatting at all. Content should be extremely similar but not at all duplicate. I’m thinking something along the line of recipes with the bogus phrase being a key ingredient – not lorum ipsum gibberish. It needs to look like real content, and I’m thinking not optimized for anything on page.
- Submit site maps, and wait to be indexed. In the mean time don’t give any link love at all, and hopefully no one else would either.
Now my guess is that at this point the exact match domain would rank #1 and the others would fall out randomly behind it.
- Now 301 the exact match to one of the others and see if it now consistently ranks at the top.
Another experiment that could be done simultaneously with the same domains plus another (different) exact match domain would be to redirect it without it ever containing any content at all – nothing but an .htaccess file. Just to see what happens. I’ve actually done this, and it seems to work, but there are too many other factors to tell for sure.
I realize that a larger number of domains and repetitions of the test would be required for defensibly valid results, but this is what I have resources for, and I think that if it’s properly executed this could yield worthwhile results.
Questions? Comments? Predictions? Anyone see any problems with the method? Anyone know if this has already been tried?














